Compare the three ways to buy

The payment, the cash to close, and what is left to pay

Cash to Close
Assumption

Assumption only

$1,813/mo
Lowest payment
Down payment
$427,857
Funds due
$441,497
Interest + MI left
$66,801
First ends
Nov 2040
Assumption

Assumption + second

$4,456/mo
+$2,644/mo
Down payment
$58,857
Funds due
$75,862
Interest + MI left
$649,483
First ends
Nov 2040
New loan

New conventional

$4,164/mo
+$2,351/mo
Down payment
$58,857
Funds due
$72,531
Interest + MI left
$774,817
First ends
Feb 2057

Monthly payment

The initial total housing payment for each option.

Assumption onlyAssumption + secondNew conventional
First mortgage$152,143$152,143$521,143
Second mortgage—$369,000—
First P&I$1,318.94$1,318.94$3,565.72
Second P&I—$2,643.56—
Mortgage insurance——$104.23
Taxes, insurance & HOA$493.67$493.67$493.67
Total housing payment$1,812.61$4,456.17$4,163.62

Cash to close

Down payment, closing costs and prepaids, then credits.

Down payment$58,857
Closing costs & prepaids$17,005
Usable credit−$0
Total buyer cash needed$75,862
Earnest money paid−$0
Remaining funds due$75,862
Assumption fee$763.00
Credit report$200.00
Tax service$80.00
UMe assumption specialist (1%)$5,800.00
Title & settlement$1,825.00
Recording fee$100.00
VA funding fee (0.5%)$760.71
Second-loan charges$1,250.00
Home insurance (12 months up front)$2,000.00
Insurance escrow (3 months)$500.00
Property tax escrow (3 months)$696.00
Initial HOA (3 months)$285.00
Prepaid interest, first (27 days)$630.25
Prepaid interest, second (27 days)$2,115.43

Prepaids include a year of home insurance up front, three months of taxes and insurance in escrow, and 27 days of interest to the end of the closing month.

What is left to pay

The seller already paid down the early, interest-heavy years.

Remaining first mortgage at closing13 yr 10 moOf the original 15-year loan at 5.6%
Interest already paid$10,231Through Jan 2027
Assumption only · ends Nov 2040$66,801
Assumption + second · ends Nov 2040, second Feb 2057$649,483
New conventional · ends Feb 2057$774,817